I actually have both the digital and dial calipers. I think the dial ones are older, 18+ years I believe. Still prefer the digital ones. I toss the calipers when the faces get worn and he faces don't come together all the way down when closed. I have thrown both digital and dial calipers away in the last 38 years when they wear out.
Richard W.
Digital Height Gage
I still rely on a vernier caliper purchased in early '58, as I recall. It no longer is able to do fine work, but it's great for checking size of stock. It's a vernier Helios.
Even with my diminished eye capacity, I still like a vernier scale. It never has to be reset, nor does the battery die in the middle of a project.
Harold
Even with my diminished eye capacity, I still like a vernier scale. It never has to be reset, nor does the battery die in the middle of a project.
Harold
Dial type instruments are quit often looked at as not as accurate as the same something in digital. Lots of the errors in parts I inspect are due to people not realizing the zero button was pushed or a preset is wrong and they measure without verifying the tools. Twits actually. Oops did I say that! Vernier and dial tools are much less likely to be out.
A month ago I was asked to measure a process test part that was made to .030 thick and our ultrasonic gauges only read to .060. I used a dial indicator in a "long C" shaped holder with a pin under the indicator tip to reach. I wrote all the numbers I read on the part with a black Sharpie. The part was sent to the customer and they did the same with their Ultrasonic that can read to .007 and wrote in blue. In the mean time the company bought a $5,000 plus Ultrasonic like customer's and when we got the part back I did it again with it and recorded in red. All three readings at each location was within .001 of each other. Shows you don't need the fancy toys to measure accurately. Especially in a home shop!
Pete
A month ago I was asked to measure a process test part that was made to .030 thick and our ultrasonic gauges only read to .060. I used a dial indicator in a "long C" shaped holder with a pin under the indicator tip to reach. I wrote all the numbers I read on the part with a black Sharpie. The part was sent to the customer and they did the same with their Ultrasonic that can read to .007 and wrote in blue. In the mean time the company bought a $5,000 plus Ultrasonic like customer's and when we got the part back I did it again with it and recorded in red. All three readings at each location was within .001 of each other. Shows you don't need the fancy toys to measure accurately. Especially in a home shop!
Pete
-
- Posts: 2281
- Joined: Sat Jan 04, 2003 8:33 pm
- Location: 40 Miles West of Chicago/near DeKalb
- Contact:
Exactly why I like digital calipers. No gears are racks to get dirty.I have found the dial tools to be more likely to be out. They can skip a tooth on dust in the gears. I got a new set of coolant proof digital calipers and they seem to work just fine. (8" Mitutoyo)
The vernier height gage, calipers, and the slide rule have never needed new batteries. I bought the slide rule when I was in 8th grade. It was mounted to my Honda 350 for several years for checking gas mileage. Today, the slide rule is in my 2002 Ford Ranger for the same reason.
Jim
Tool & Die Maker/Electrician, Retired 2007
So much to learn and so little time.
www.outbackmachineshop.com
So much to learn and so little time.
www.outbackmachineshop.com